Reviews
A Toronto Star “16 reads for summer weekends” selection
A Brightly “10 Brand-New Books to Add to Your TBR List This Month” selection
“Captivating . . . consistently surprising and hilarious. . . . The book includes a plethora of lively literary and cultural references in footnotes, sidebars, and illustrations. This novel is an inventive delight, perfectly pitched to omnivorous readers.”
—Publishers Weekly (starred review)
“Immigrant, Montana is a beguiling meditation on memory and migration, sex and politics, ideas and art, and race and ambiguity. Part novel, part memoir, this book is as sly, charming, and deceptive as its passionate protagonist, a writer writing himself into being.”
—Viet Thanh Nguyen, Pulitzer Prize Winner and author of The Sympathizer
“There is a buoyant energy and hilarity to this account of an Indian student seeking the wide world through the women he meets, but one laughs with growing unease as a darker undercurrent is slowly revealed. An unusual, brave twist on the migrant’s tale.”
—Kiran Desai, winner of the Man Booker Prize for The Inheritance of Loss
“Amitava Kumar's Immigrant, Montana is romantic, natural, gorgeously detailed, and painfully truthful about exile, grad school, sex and the South Asian man. Few novels have captured the mental texture of immigration so accurately.”
—Karan Mahajan, author of The Association of Small Bombs
“Apparently, Amitava Kumar once considered calling this book The Man Without a Country, which is indeed what it's about—the eros of crossing and crisscrossing borders, the necessity of jumping boundaries, the excitement of refusing to place people and books in categories. An urgant, galvanizing work.”
—David Shields, author of Reality Hunger and Other People
“Amitava Kumar's novel brings to mind W. G. Sebald's work, but Kumar has a deeper curiosity in the borderless-ness of storytelling as a confrontation to all kinds of borders imposed upon his characters by the external and the artificial, as we see more and more in today's world. Audacious in its scope yet with refreshing attention to detail, Immigrant, Montana is one of those novels that, with each rereading, a reader will unlock another treasure of joy.”
—Yiyun Li, author of Dear Friend, from My Life I write to You in Your Life
“Novels are a form of settled entertainment by now. People go to them for what they are sure of finding. Novels are read and generally rewarded for the ease of their consumption. In this sense, they’ve become rather like television series, but at least television series don’t pretend to be other than they are. The hundreds of novels that are published each year are for the most part inconsequential, with the inconsequentiality underscored by their heaviness (heaviness rather than gravity). The exceptions prove this rule: in the works of JM Coetzee, Penelope Fitzgerald, Rachel Cusk, John Berger, VS Naipaul, or Ben Lerner—stylistically different though they are—one is relieved to find that the novel is not dead. What do these books have in common? They understand the role of freedom in the forward motion of a narrative, they are free without folly, they have a real freedom tightly bound to craft. The sentences sing in the dark. Immigrant, Montana is a book in this class, and easily the best new novel I have read in recent years.”
—Teju Cole, author of Open City
“As cerebral as it is sensual, and as slippery in nature as it is insightful. . . . Immigrant, Montana is intelligent, melancholy, quirky. At a time when feelings run high over which immigrants get to call themselves American, Kailash’s idiosyncratic voice adds a welcome tonic note to the debate.”
—The Boston Globe
“A portrait of a mind moving uneasily between a new, chosen culture and the one left behind. . . . Immigrant, Montana . . . [channels] the pleasure of the most satisfying nonfiction books, the ones in which the reader sees the old anew.”
—The New Yorker
“This novel fearlessly unmasks some great men, making political stalwarts and revolutionaries stumble down from their pedestals.”
—The Guardian
"Written with humor, insight, and longing, Immigrant, Montana is at its core an investigation of love and its ability to shape, reshape, or destroy borders."
—PEN America
“Immigrant, Montana is a delight.”
—Hanif Kureishi, author of Intimacy
“This is a deeply American novel, one that delves into the messiness of love (and sex!), and the meeting point between identity, character, place, and the constant cultural stuff floating around. I was reminded, strangely, reading it, not only of our contemporary explorers—Teju Cole and Ben Lerner and Lydia Davis—but also Woody Allen and Philip Roth, and so many others who had the skill and talent and, above all, the humor to do whatever was necessary to delve into the lives of their characters, even if it meant breaking with traditions and incorporating new ways of using the materials of the culture: we are, their work says, not only internal beings struggling for love and meaning in our lives, but also complex amalgamation of cultural and historical information. Above all, Kumar's novel was uproariously funny and deeply moving.”
—David Means, author of Hystopia
“Full of stirring insights into the Indian immigrant’s cultural experience, including his various, often unfulfilling, sexual exploits, this is a very funny, frank novel with shades of early Roth, Updike and Woody Allen. Damn fine.”
—The Big Issue
“The bio-fictional novel plays out like an emotional composition, layered with news clippings, diary notations, photographs, historical essays, literary quotes and pop-culture references as outsider Kailash tries to navigate his new home.”
—The Star
“Immigrant, Montana is an unusually bold take [told] in an effortless and refreshing style. Listed as one of the best books of 2018 by the New Yorker magazine, Immigrant, Montana will force you to follow your own migration trajectory."
—The American Bazaar